The Creative Tension of Mental Illness

Originally published May 2018


I’m Bernie Sheahan. I’m creative…and mentally ill. There are many categories of mental illness; I’m an expert on just one.

The novelist William Styron called it “darkness visible” in his best-selling memoir of the same name; for me, depression is a gray, stoop-shouldered monster that has stalked me throughout my adult life. Three years ago, my doctor made official what others had long suspected, that I had bipolar disorder, also known as manic depression.

It’s right up there with schizophrenia in the “severe mental illness” category, but I’m somewhere between Bipolar I and Bipolar II. I may never have “classic” manic episodes (though my house could use a four-day cleaning frenzy), the kind that have a devastating effect on sufferers and their loved ones, especially when the high takes the inevitable tumble. Mine’s more like Tigger’s bounce—more diverting than dangerous.

And I’m not alone. Famous bipolar artists include the likes of John Keats, Tennessee Williams, and Georgia O’Keefe. A connection between creativity and mental illness has long been assumed. Stanford researchers have discovered in the brains of both the highly creative and the mentally ill an inability to filter outside stimuli—but that doesn’t mean mental illness necessarily gives you a creative edge.

A connection between creativity and mental illness has long been assumed…but that doesn’t mean mental illness necessarily gives you a creative edge.

That would be like saying you have to drink to be a writer. I lived in Oxford, Mississippi, for two glorious years and I breathed William Faulkner’s air. Literally every day I jogged the Faulkner-to-Faulkner route, from his grave near my apartment, past his famed Confederate soldier monument in the square, to his backyard at Rowan Oak. I gulped the cedar-scented wind and wondered every day why he drank.

Poor Mr. Will wrote about sin and pain more profoundly than nearly any American in the 20th century. He suffered crushing depressions. And he medicated himself with bourbon. As Styron wrote,“Faulkner and others drank to broaden their vision, their exaltation or despair, or to flee from the pure agony of creation.”

But I know another reason why Faulkner drank. I thought about it when I stood at his grave or when I sat in St. Peter’s Episcopal Church, where he was a member. In all his profundity, in mining the depth of Old Testament justice and mercy within the Southern psyche, Faulkner never learned to appropriate that mercy for himself. I imagine him experiencing only judgment—and at his own hands.

Faulkner never learned to appropriate mercy for himself. I imagine him experiencing only judgment—and at his own hands.

C.S. Lewis, one of his fellow Anglicans (albeit a more devout one) wrote this: “Whenever you are fed up with life, start writing: Ink is the great cure for all human ills, as I have found out long ago.” (This is taped to my laptop.)

The difference between the two writers is that while Lewis found life in the ink, Faulkner found despair. As a writer, enlivened by grace, Lewis was healed through the work (see his book, Surprised by Joy, for details). I, too, know that the work of writing helps heal.

So do loving relationships, long walks, and good medications (I’m on four). I’m thankful for all of these things, which, when I take life one day at a time, allow me not only to read the Psalmist’s words but to know what he’s talking about; to marvel at the firmament rather than get stuck to its ceiling; to acknowledge the bottom of the miry pit without wallowing in it, sucking black mud into my lungs. Living somewhere between the extremes is a good thing—and a lot less scary for those who love me.

Jesus said, “I came that you might have life, and have it more abundantly.” Those of us who are in the arts, either as creators or appreciators, experience life and its abundance on many levels, and give thanks for subtleties that others may not notice. It’s our privilege to awaken the world to beauty through what we create and appreciate with others, to reveal the Light and expose the darkness. In some of us, the darkness is painfully visible.

As artists, this is both our burden and our gift. As an artist with a mental illness and a deep faith in Christ, I live daily within this tension.

Bernie Sheahan is a writer, historian, and sometime radio host.

You may also want to read

Las Vegas, Gun Violence, and the Church

By Jon Carlson

Is it genocide?
Cause I can still hear his mama cry
Know the family traumatized
Shots left holes in his face about piranha-sized
The old pastor closed the cold casket, and said the church ain’t got enough room for all the tombs.

Civil Religion: Caution Is Advised

By John Seel with Ray Pennings

Henry Van Til observes that “culture is religion externalized.” By this, he meant that the culture of a people reflects their true religious priorities. So the existence of civil religion is not ultimately surprising.